POETRY029 / POETRY

BETTER TO HAVE LOVED AND LOST, THAN...

I made a promise once to become easier to understand

and harder to misunderstand others. It was not quite a promise to be good.

Good is a word people use when they want the accounting to be simple. I wanted something more difficult.

I wanted to learn the particular grammar

of the people I loved—which silences meant leave me alone, which meant please notice,

when help was a pair of hands and when it was the discipline of keeping mine to myself.

I wanted to stop mistaking what I knew how to give

for what another person needed.

So I studied. I studied apology. I studied grief.

I studied the thousand disguises of fear. I learned that anger sometimes arrives wearing somebody else's name.

That reassurance given too late can sound like an argument.

That some people need a witness, some need a door held open,

some need you to sit on the floor beside them

and resist the unbearable urge to make anything better. I wrote some of it down.

At first, only for myself. A record of the person I was trying to become.

A way of making the promise difficult to deny later when keeping it became inconvenient.

Because I knew myself well enough to know that conviction is easiest before it costs anything.

And eventually it cost something. Of course it did.

There were people I learned carefully who still misunderstood me. People whose language I practiced

until my mouth hurt who would not speak mine.

There were times I arrived with exactly what I had been asked to carry

and found the house empty.

There were times I stayed too long because I had confused endurance with devotion.

Times I did too much. Times the kindest thing available to me

was restraint, and I had to learn that too.

I learned that love is not made purer by exhausting the person giving it.

I learned that leaving can require as much care as staying. I learned that understanding someone does not obligate me to survive them. None of this was in the first draft

of the promise.

Neither was the part where doing everything carefully still sometimes ends badly.

That was an expensive amendment. There is no arrangement of tenderness that guarantees tenderness in return.

No fluency so perfect that nobody can choose not to hear you.

No amount of deliberate living that prevents the accidental thing

from entering through an unlocked afternoon and changing the shape of everything.

People leave. People die.

People become strangers while their coffee is still in your cupboard.

Bodies betray their tenants.

Homes empty. Dogs grow gray around the mouth. There are roads you drive every day until one day you drive them

for the last time without knowing to look around.

There are versions of yourself you will never be able to visit again. Loss has never needed love's permission. This is the part I keep returning to.

People tell you, after enough of it,

to become careful. They usually mean smaller.

Give less. Expect less. Need less.

Let fewer things reach the soft machinery.

And perhaps it works.

Perhaps there is a life in which I perfect the art

of having nothing left to take. I don't think I want it.

Not because I have mistaken pain for proof that something mattered.

Pain has never needed that kind of encouragement.

But because I have noticed that loss is remarkably resourceful.

It finds us anyway. It takes years. It takes places.

It takes the familiar shape of a room after the furniture has been moved.

It takes people we never thought we would have to practice remembering.

Even without love, there would still be things

I could not keep. And if I am going to lose things anyway,

I cannot understand making a life

with less love in it just to give grief fewer names. I would rather know the names.

I would rather have known how someone takes their coffee, what makes them go quiet,

which story they tell differently

when they are tired.

I would rather learn that one person wants questions and another wants company

without having to explain themselves.

I would rather know who needs the light left on.

There is so much about another person

that can only be learned by considering them worth the study.

And I do. God, I do. Not everyone.

That has never been the promise. But when I choose someone, when I make room for them

inside the small and deliberate country

of my life, I want to learn the roads.

I want to know where not to drive. I want to know which doors stick, which floorboards announce you, where they keep the extra blankets, what they mean when they say

I'm fine

and, just as importantly, when they simply mean

I'm fine. I want to become fluent enough not to translate everything

back into myself.

And I will get it wrong. There are languages

I will never speak without an accent.

There will be days when I bring comfort

to someone who needed space, days when I mistake silence for an invitation to fill it,

days when all my careful learning still leaves me standing there with the wrong thing in my hands.

The promise was never to become impossible to fail. It was to remain teachable.

To let someone tell me

that isn't how you love me

without answering

but look how hard I tried.

To understand that effort is not the same thing as accuracy.

To change. To remember.

To try differently next time. And maybe that is all I have ever meant

by leaving nothing accidental.

Not perfection. Not some impossible tenderness that always knows what to do.

Just attention. The willingness to learn the shape of another person

without insisting they resemble me.

To let knowing them change the way I know how to care.

To keep some record of what I have learned and remain willing

to revise it.

There are easier ways to move through the world.

I know.

But I have never wanted to become untouched by it.

I want a life that leaves evidence of having been lived among people. Their words in my vocabulary.

Their recipes in my kitchen. Their names attached to songs

and streets and stupid jokes

I will never be able to explain correctly.

The particular ways I have learned to be gentle

because once,

someone needed gentleness in exactly that form. What a privilege, really,

to be changed by having known someone.

To carry forward some small instruction their existence gave me

for how to meet the next person a little more carefully. So I will keep learning. I will keep asking.

I will keep becoming someone capable of loving people

more particularly than I did before. Not because I expect

to master it. There are too many languages and I have only one life.

But I have one. And while I am here,

I would like to spend it

getting better

at saying

I see you

in as many ways

as I can.

Whatever you take from this place, that matters.